Americans' AI Skepticism Runs Deeper Than Job Loss Fears

Derek Thompson argues that public hostility toward AI exceeds what labor displacement alone explains. The anxiety taps into something more fundamental: control, autonomy, and how Americans want to experience consumption and work. The gap between elite enthusiasm and mass skepticism reflects a deeper concern—whether AI serves consumer preferences or replaces the human judgment that gives people agency in their choices. Technologies that ignore how ordinary people want to exercise choice will face sustained political and cultural resistance, not transient skepticism.