Student Phone Bans Show Small Learning Gains, But Evidence Remains Mixed

A Harvard analysis of 3 million test scores found that locking up phones during school days recovered about half the learning losses U.S. students experienced since 2013—meaningful enough that gains persisted three years after adoption—but conflicting peer-reviewed research and methodological concerns prevent this from becoming settled policy. Schools face genuine productivity losses from devices, yet the technical fix of Yondr pouches isn't assured, leaving administrators to weigh incremental gains against enforcement friction. Gen Z's actual indifference to AI contradicts the "most anti-AI generation" narrative and suggests teenagers are pragmatic adopters rather than ideological holdouts, which may matter more for edtech adoption than the phone-ban question itself.